How to Test a Text Field

(Heather) #1

I saw a blog post from @maaret not too long ago about How Would You Test a Text Field?

As you might have guessed, I really like these “How to Test” questions. I love the ideas that are generated around them and the discussions we have.

If I were to answer this myself, the first two things that would spring to mind are more the “What I would use to test a text field”. I would have to have the big list of naughty strings to hand! I would also have something like PerlClip or some other type of random string generator ready to quickly generate text of known length.

What about you? How would you test a text field?

(Andrew) #2

How is copy-pasting supposed to work in the field: text only, with formatting, with media?
formatting as markup or WYSIWIG?
word wrap, resize, sensible scroll wheel and scroll bar behaviour…
keep focus when I’d expect it to
word wrap as display or by inserting CRs?
word wrapping changes when resizing?
what if you paste in a spreadsheet/table, how does that show?
when you copy out of it, again how does that work into other editors: notepad, Word, web pages?
How does it handle OSKs? Do they obscure important controls?
Can the box auto-expand over other items if you enter a lot?

(Andrew) #3

If it has a default or pre-filled value from some previous editing of that field, does that always come in correctly, is it already “select-all”-ed (should it be? )?

(Paul) #4

I have an Excel file with columns corresponding to random fuzz type data that can break a UI textfield or command line. You may find it useful.

(Brian) #5

As is typical of me, I would start with asking questions about the text field. What is it for? Why am I entering text? What are the limits of the text I am entering? Should I expect an output? If so, what? Is the text field in an app? in a website? on an interface with an embedded system (think IoT)?

At some point, I should know enough to create test data, then the tools can come into play.

A handy mindmap

Another interesting thought experiment:
Someone puts a text field in front of you and gives you the assignment to test the field. You know nothing about the text field besides the name of the field is “text field”. How would you test this field?

(Heather) #6

Mindmaps are always something I struggle with. I’ve seen many people use them effectively but I’ve never managed to do so myself I don’t think.

(Stefan) #7

It is interesting to read this type of questions and even this article and see functional tester (beginner or advanced) answers.
I, just as you, enjoy reading various opinions on this topic types.

So one of the first rules of testing…Ask questions about the context.

I would try to understand what is a text field to that person asking.
Are we talking about a part of a text inside a paragraph? a text on a field(label)? a text inside a box(placeholder)? a text using a lawn mower on a field of grass? a text on a paper surrounded by a margin?

What is the person trying to figure out from me?
Is it how I think about a problem, how I find ideas, how I would write a test in TDD for that, how I would automate a check for that field, how I would present that feature in a demo, how I write test-cases…

What is relevant to the person asking the question?
How much time do I have to answer it?
How would the answer have to be? spoken/paper/digital/chatted?

From what perspective do I test?
What am I when I test it? A tester, a user, a person buying the software…?

And so on…
What interaction can I do with this text field?
Context about hardware and software of this field?
What does this field integrate with?
Who, how many, why, when…etc. users use this field?
And on…

(Alex) #8

I once went on a final interview where I expected to talk about salary and a start date and was hit with a question that haunts me even until today. How would a test the twitter textbox? I’ll be honest and tell you that I froze. Since then that question has haunted me for a long time. I was so disappointed in myself that I never followed up on answering that question for myself.

This question brought back that nightmare for me. I wish I could go back to that day and shake myself and tell myself to get the context of such a question and from there begin to develop a point of attack. Anyways, great points made so far on how to test.

What would I do?
Well, considering a context similar to the Twitter textbox, I would consider the following:

  • First, I’d gather information on what features the textbox has, in the case of twitter I would consider the following features list to start my exploratory test session:

    • I18N compliant
    • Hashtag and name tag referencing
    • string limits
    • string counter (not really part of the textbox but very much tied to it)
    • handling of emoji
    • interaction with other plugins such as Grammarly
    • accessibility compliant
  • In order to explore the features listed above, I would consider the following types of tests:

    • exploratory testing to cover string limits, string counter, handling of emoji, interaction with other plugins, accessibility compliant, i18n handling, and many other ideas that will pop into my head as I explore.
    • localization testing and string manipulation to cover I18N compliance
    • performance testing (load, stress, volume) in order to cover hashtag and name tag referencing.
    • light security testing to cover SQL injection, access to textbox as an unauthorized user, etc.

I’m sure there is much more that could be covered but this is just a quick analysis of what I would start doing to test a textbox similar to the Twitter textbox. :slight_smile:

(Hannah) #9

Hey everyone,

Great ideas. I decided to compile them in a Google Doc with a few of my on ideas because I’ve been wanting a better way to reference test ideas for a while.

Comments and suggestions for a better format for something like this very welcome :slight_smile:

(permissions updated)

(Gavin) #10

Quick questions about the text box:
Is the text field the best input at that time?
What happends to the text that is input into it? Does it get read and used within the software? If yes, is the text box used/read by different parts of the software for differt reasons or always the same part of the software? If different, does the validation argument change between the different parts of the software.
What should happen if invalid data is entered?
Is there a standard entry format (think UK licence plates that generally follow a form but in reality can be anything within reason)?
Does it have to be used in multiple countries and therefore allow different languages to be entered?
Can the text in it be formatted?
Can the delete key be used in it?
Is it multilined?

Just a couple of questions I would be asking (sorry that some are repeats of other peoples.