Evaluating WinappDriver/Appium ... Any one with experience out there!

My organisation build desktop applications.
I have been requested to Evaluate WinAppDriver/Appium
Below are the Acceptance Criterias

  1. GUI testing
  2. It is stable
  3. It can run on virtual machine
  4. It Supports record and playback
  5. It can integrate to jira

I would highly appreciate any help with experience
Thanks